Skip to main content

Ten-day indoor prayer retreat attended by 'several hundred people' at New Hampshire church who 'removed their masks to sing' leads to COVID-19 outbreak

A 10-day indoor prayer retreat for parishioners at a church in New Hampshire led to an outbreak of the novel coronavirus.

It is estimated that 'several hundred people' attended the event at Gate City Church, in Nashua, which ran from September 18 to September 29.

So far, nine people who participated in the retreat have tested positive for COVID-19, the disease caused by the virus. 

Bobbie Bagley, director of the Nashua Department of Public Health & Community Services , said although safety guidelines were mostly followed, families did remove their masks to sing, which was likely the precipitating factor in the outbreak.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has encouraged Americans to avoid singing because it can contribute to the spread of COVID-19. 

'Avoid singing, chanting, or shouting, especially when not wearing a mask and within feet of others,' the website states.

Additionally, if singing is to be done, it is recommended to wear a mask or face covering at all times.  

An indoor prayer retreat was held at Gate City Church (pictured), in Nashua, New Hampshire, from September 18 to September 29, with masks being removed to sing

An indoor prayer retreat was held at Gate City Church , in Nashua, New Hampshire, from September 18 to September 29, with masks being removed to sing

Nine people who attended the event have tested positive for COVID-19 and several hundred more are being asked to get tested, with the church moving all services online (above)

Nine people who attended the event have tested positive for COVID-19 and several hundred more are being asked to get tested, with the church moving all services online

During a news conference on Thursday, Nashua Mayor Jim Donchess said the state discovered the outbreak on October 5.  

'Since then, our public health department has been working with the state and with the church to try to identify anyone who might have been in contact with a positive case,' he said.

At the conference, Bagley said 'patient zero' was likely an asymptomatic person who did not know that they were infected with COVID-19.

She said the church followed state guidelines, including having families placed six to 10 feet apart and ensuring that people were wearing masks. 

But, at one point during the retreat, congregants 'did take their masks off once they were in their family units to sing.'

'Singing...in an enclosed building is one of the riskiest exposure opportunities with the virus,' Bagley said.

'And although there was nothing that was intended to cause any harm, this situation did allow for extended exposure at this church.'

She added that one of the earliest known cases had symptoms as early as September 26.

NDPH is currently performing contact tracing and monitoring the symptoms of those with confirmed cases.

Officials encourage anyone who who attended events held by the church since September 19 to get tested for the virus.

Gate City Church did not immediately return DailyMail.com's request for comment.

However, according to a notice posted on the church's website, all services will be online only until further notice. 

'We have had a few of our members test positive for COVID-19 and while we do not operate in fear, we want to take every step necessary to mitigate your exposure and to be safe,' the notice reads.

'Please know that these are not large numbers and understand that these are not Gate City Church Staff.'

This is not the only coronavirus outbreak linked to a church in New Hampshire since the pandemic began.

In August, it was reported that at least 16 people who attended events hosted Crossing Life Church in Windham contracted COVID-19.

CDC SAYS SINGING CAN INCREASE THE RISK OF COVID-19

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has encouraged Americans to avoid singing because it can spread COVID-19.

'Avoid singing, chanting, or shouting, especially when not wearing a mask and within feet of others,' the website states.

Additionally, if singing is to be done, it is recommended to wear a mask or face covering at all times. 

A CDC study even found the 'act of singing' likely contributed to 53 of 61 people who attended a choir rehearsal in March in Washington state contracting COVID-19, two of whom later died.

In May, the CDC posted guidance on its website suggesting houses of worship should limit choir activities.

'Consider suspending or at least decreasing use of a choir/musical ensembles and congregant singing, chanting, or reciting during services or other programming, if appropriate within the faith tradition,' the statement read.

'The act of singing may contribute to transmission of COVID-19, possibly through emission of aerosols.'

However, less than one week later, the wording was removed. According to senior officials, it had been published by mistake and was not approved by the White House.

The recommendations on the website now read: 'Promote social distancing at services and other gatherings, ensuring that clergy, staff, choir, volunteers and attendees at the services follow social distancing, as circumstances and faith traditions allow, to lessen their risk.'

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The HS2 money pit: Ministers are told first stage of high-speed rail line may cost another £800m... six months after a budget increase saw total costs soar by £20.6bn to £43billion

Ministers have been told that Phase One of controversial rail line HS2 could cost £800million more than planned. It comes just six months after a budget increase saw total predicted costs for the first stage of the high-speed line soar by £20.6billion to £43billion. In a written statement to Parliament, HS2 Minister Andrew Stephenson said half of this figure is due to preparation of the route for construction involving 'more significant challenges than anticipated'. This includes the need to remove more asbestos than expected. Another 'significant cost pressure' worth £400 million has also been identified during the development of designs for Euston station. Mr Stephenson warned that further investigation is being carried out which 'could identify further pressure'. Ministers have been told that Phase One of controversial rail line HS2 could cost £800million more than planned. Pictured: HS2 Minister Andrew Stephenson The HS2 route would initially link London and...

EXCLUSIVE: From a $US13million mansion to a caravan: How the Australian wife of Il Divo singer has been 'forced' to live in a dodgy trailer park after a wildfire burned down their house during a bitter divorce battle

'Forced' into a 'mobile home park': Renee Izambard (nee Murphy) with her estranged husband, the suave Il Divo opera singer Sebastien Izambard An Il Divo opera singer's estranged Australian wife claims she was 'forced' to live in a caravan park after their $US12.95million Malibu mansion burned down in a wildfire days just after she filed for divorce.  Details of one-time Sydney Sony Music executive Renee Izambard's new life after her messy split with French tenor Sebastien Izambard were laid bare in a lawsuit filed with a Californian court this week. Ms Izambard (nee Murphy) is suing insurer State Farm, her estranged husband, an insurance agent and up to 20 others, over an allegedly 'inadequate' policy which covered the couple's destroyed former Malibu home.  Their five bedroom residence - described as a 'no expense spared ... oasis' - and its two guest houses went up in flames on November 8, 2018 during California's devastating Wo...

Missouri police resume search for body of mother, 28, believed to have been 'suffocated by her husband who wanted to stop her fleeing to her native China with their daughter' a year ago

A year after a young Chinese mother living in Missouri with her family vanished without a trace, police have resumed the search for her body.  Mengqi Ji Elledge, 28, was reported missing by her husband, Joseph Elledge, on October 10, 2019. He was charged in February with first-degree murder in her death and has pleaded not guilty. The couple has a young daughter together. Joseph has been accused of suffocating his wife to death and disposing of her body in order to prevent her from returning to her native China with their child and to avoid a costly divorce.    Police in Missouri are renewing their efforts to locate the body of Mengqi Ji Elledge, 28, who went missing last October and is presumed dead. Her husband, Joseph Elledge, was charged in February with first-degree murder in her death Police had searched for Mengqi's remains with divers, sonar and heavy machinery at the Lamine River near Booneville after cadaver dogs hit on a scent there Police had searched for her remains wi...