Skip to main content

Philadelphia cop is charged with first-degree MURDER over fatal 2017 shooting of unarmed black man following high-speed car chase

Former Philadelphia cop Eric Ruch Jr., 33, has been charged with first-degree murder, third-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter, and possession of an instrument of crime over the 2017 shooting of Dennis Plowden Jr.

Former Philadelphia cop Eric Ruch Jr., 33, has been charged with first-degree murder, third-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter, and possession of an instrument of crime over the 2017 shooting of Dennis Plowden Jr.

A Philadelphia cop has been charged with first-degree murder after he fatally shot an unarmed black man following a high-speed police chase. 

Officer Eric Ruch Jr., 33, shot and killed Dennis Plowden Jr., 25, on December 27, 2017 after pursuing Plowden's vehicle, allegedly believing it was linked to an active homicide case. 

Authorities claim Plowden crashed his car at 77 mph before he stumbled out and fell to the ground. He was reportedly holding his empty left hand in front of his face when Ruch fired the fatal shot. 

Four other officers who were on the scene and had taken cover did not fire their weapons, according to a grand jury, who handed down their decision on Friday.  

Plowden was taking classes to get his high school diploma at the time of his killing. He left behind two children and three stepchildren, including an infant son who is now three years old.  

Dennis Plowden Jr. is pictured with his wife Tania Bond in a social media snap taken before his December 2017 death. Bond is now suing Officer Ruch, three other cops, and the city of Philadelphia

Dennis Plowden Jr. is pictured with his wife Tania Bond in a social media snap taken before his December 2017 death. Bond is now suing Officer Ruch, three other cops, and the city of Philadelphia 


On Friday, the grand jury said Ruch shot Plowden in the head without justification as Plowden looked 'dazed and lost on the sidewalk.' 

'Ruch intentionally fired on Dennis Plowden less than 20 seconds after the Hyundai he had been driving crashed at nearly 80 miles an hour, Mr. Plowden had fallen to the ground, and yet was still attempting to obey commands,' the grand jury wrote.

Ruch, who was fired about 10 months after the shooting, turned himself in Friday to face charges of first-degree murder, third-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and possession of an instrument of crime. 

Prosecutors expected Ruch to be held without bail. 

Officer Ruch and his partner began pursuing Plowden in the white Hyundai. He crashed his car at high speed and then rolled out of the vehicle. He was unarmed and on the ground at the time he was shot

Officer Ruch and his partner began pursuing Plowden in the white Hyundai. He crashed his car at high speed and then rolled out of the vehicle. He was unarmed and on the ground at the time he was shot 

Police are pictured at the scene of the shooting in Philadelphia on December 27, 2017

Police are pictured at the scene of the shooting in Philadelphia on December 27, 2017

The police union said its lawyers will defend the former officer.

'We will represent former police officer Eric Ruch Jr. against these serious charges. Our attorneys will review the allegations and appropriately defend this officer,' said John McNesby, president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 5.

'Officer Ruch Jr. is entitled to due process, and we believe the judicial system will protect his rights to a fair trial.'

Paul Hetznecker, who represents Plowden's wife, Tania Bond, called the charges 'long overdue' and 'an important step in the struggle for racial and social justice in this city.' 

Bond is suing Ruch, three other officers and the city.

It remained unclear why police sought to stop Plowden's car in the first place. According to the grand jury, Ruch and his partner began following Plowden and asked police dispatch to check the registration of his car.

Ruch's partner told investigators after the shooting that they had stopped Plowden's Hyundai because of a patrol alert that connected it to a homicide, according to the grand jury.

Plowden was taking classes to get his high school diploma and was learning the construction trade at the time of his killing. He left behind two children and three stepchildren, including an infant son who is now three years old. Plowden is pictured with his wife Tania Bond

Plowden was taking classes to get his high school diploma and was learning the construction trade at the time of his killing. He left behind two children and three stepchildren, including an infant son who is now three years old. Plowden is pictured with his wife Tania Bond 

But other officers said they were unaware of the patrol alert - which had not been broadcast over police radio - and all the information sought by Ruch from police dispatch was already contained in the alert.

'There's no information on the police radio before the incident that indicates that anyone knew for sure that this vehicle may have been involved in a homicide,' Assistant District Attorney Vincent Corrigan said at a news conference Friday. That homicide investigation remains open, he said, but the Hyundai is no longer an 'avenue of inquiry.'

The grand jury said three of the four officers present for the shooting testified they did not see Plowden raise his left hand, while the fourth said he didn't recall what Plowden was doing with it.

Other eyewitnesses said Plowden was on his back and struggling to sit up when he was shot, with one saying Plowden was gesturing with his left hand in front of his face.

Plowden is pictured in an old social media photo taken before his December 27, 2017 death

Plowden is pictured in an old social media photo taken before his December 27, 2017 death 

The lawsuit filed by Plowden's wife said he was propping himself up with his right arm while holding out his left hand in a vain attempt to prevent Ruch from shooting him. 

A medical examiner said the bullet tore through the fingers of Plowden´s left hand before hitting him in the head, indicating the hand was raised, according to the grand jury.

Officers also said they saw Plowden's right hand in his pocket, with one saying 'it looked like he had a gun in there,' the grand jury said. The other eyewitnesses did not mention Plowden's right hand.

Ruch fired the fatal shot just 6 to 8 seconds after getting to the crash scene, the grand jury said.

Hetznecker, the lawyer for Plowden's wife, said that police had no probable cause to stop the car, and that officers' statements were an attempt to justify the fatal shooting.

'I'm glad to see the grand jurors saw through that,' he said.

'I am happy that Ruch was charged with the murder of Dennis,' Plowden´s wife, Tania Bond, said Friday in a phone interview with the Associated Press. 

'But this is only the beginning. There are so many more milestones before we reach the end.'

She said she wants to know 'whether Ruch has any remorse and anything to say to us. I just want to know, has Ruch ever thought about my family?'

Plowden's family are happy that Ruch has been charged with first-degree murder over the shooting. They are hoping he will now be convicted

Plowden's family are happy that Ruch has been charged with first-degree murder over the shooting. They are hoping he will now be convicted 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EXCLUSIVE: From a $US13million mansion to a caravan: How the Australian wife of Il Divo singer has been 'forced' to live in a dodgy trailer park after a wildfire burned down their house during a bitter divorce battle

'Forced' into a 'mobile home park': Renee Izambard (nee Murphy) with her estranged husband, the suave Il Divo opera singer Sebastien Izambard An Il Divo opera singer's estranged Australian wife claims she was 'forced' to live in a caravan park after their $US12.95million Malibu mansion burned down in a wildfire days just after she filed for divorce.  Details of one-time Sydney Sony Music executive Renee Izambard's new life after her messy split with French tenor Sebastien Izambard were laid bare in a lawsuit filed with a Californian court this week. Ms Izambard (nee Murphy) is suing insurer State Farm, her estranged husband, an insurance agent and up to 20 others, over an allegedly 'inadequate' policy which covered the couple's destroyed former Malibu home.  Their five bedroom residence - described as a 'no expense spared ... oasis' - and its two guest houses went up in flames on November 8, 2018 during California's devastating Wo...

The HS2 money pit: Ministers are told first stage of high-speed rail line may cost another £800m... six months after a budget increase saw total costs soar by £20.6bn to £43billion

Ministers have been told that Phase One of controversial rail line HS2 could cost £800million more than planned. It comes just six months after a budget increase saw total predicted costs for the first stage of the high-speed line soar by £20.6billion to £43billion. In a written statement to Parliament, HS2 Minister Andrew Stephenson said half of this figure is due to preparation of the route for construction involving 'more significant challenges than anticipated'. This includes the need to remove more asbestos than expected. Another 'significant cost pressure' worth £400 million has also been identified during the development of designs for Euston station. Mr Stephenson warned that further investigation is being carried out which 'could identify further pressure'. Ministers have been told that Phase One of controversial rail line HS2 could cost £800million more than planned. Pictured: HS2 Minister Andrew Stephenson The HS2 route would initially link London and...

Tests may spare school bubbles from isolating: Children could avoid disruption to lessons by being screened for Covid more often under new proposal

Ministers will explore whether children could take more Covid tests instead of self-isolating to minimise disruption to their schooling. Sajid Javid said he was seeking ‘fresh advice’ on the current policy, which sees up to 250,000 pupils miss school every day. He revealed he would discuss the subject with Education Secretary Gavin Williamson after MPs expressed concerns about children being kept at home for ten days – even after a negative PCR test – because a member of their classroom bubble has been infected. It came as the Children’s Commissioner told how pupils had experienced ‘real trauma’ during successive lockdowns. Sajid Javid said he was seeking ‘fresh advice’ on the current policy where children self-isolate, which sees up to 250,000 pupils miss school every day Dame Rachel de Souza described the class bubble system as ‘very very restrictive’, adding: ‘I think everybody would like it if we could get back to normal, as soon as possible.’ Former health minister Steve Brine tol...